Laura by Vera Caspary

[randy_byers]

THERE ARE SPOILERS.

I read this 1943 novel in the Kindle edition of Library of America's Women Crime Writers: Eight Suspense Novels of the 1940s & 50s. (Obviously the cover I'm using here is from a previous book publication.) I've seen the film adaptation several times -- and twice more since reading the novel -- and it's one of the classic film noirs. In a wonderful overview of the collection and analysis of the methods of mystery/crime fiction, film scholar David Bordwell paints Vera Caspary as quite a character: "Vera Caspary was a woman to be reckoned with —- Greenwich Village free-love practitioner, Communist party member, occasional screenwriter, boundlessly energetic purveyor of suspense fiction, passionate paramour of a married man, and advocate for women in prison." In her appreciation of the novel, Sarah Paretsky says that Caspary had strong feelings about how Laura was presented in the movie: "Caspary fought with director Otto Preminger over the way he depicted Laura’s sexuality in his 1944 film version. Caspary’s rage, as she herself called it, remained so intense that decades after the film’s release, she attacked Preminger (verbally) when she found herself seated near him at a restaurant."

I actually didn't get any sense of a strong sexuality in Laura from my own reading, but I'm willing to admit that I may have just been obtuse. I didn't get any sense that she'd had sex with her boyfriend, Shelby Carpenter, or any of her previous boyfriends, nor did I get any sense that she wanted to have sex with the detective, Mark McPherson, with whom she ends up falling in love. The only depiction of what might be considered sexual feelings on her part that I can remember is when Waldo Lydecker accuses her of a weakness for men with lithe, hard bodies.

The one major difference from the film that I picked up on is that the novel is told from four points of view: It opens (like the movie) with a section from Waldo's point of view as he tells McPherson about the history of his friendship with Laura, then (like the movie) it switches to a section from McPherson's point of view as he prowls around Laura's apartment and begins to develop feelings for her. (To my mind, this is the most sensual part of the novel, as McPherson sniffs her perfume and strokes the fabric of her clothes, almost as if he's trying to become her.) The third section is a transcript of an interview with Shelby Carpenter, which is also depicted in the film, but without the immersive flashback that characterizes Lydecker's narration. Then we get a section from Laura's point of view, and this is more or less completely missing from the film. I wonder if that's what enraged Caspary, because it turns Laura into someone without her own perspective on things; someone whom we only see through the eyes of the men who desire her. Finally the novel switches back to McPherson's point of view, which he shares with Lydecker by quoting some of his thoughts about Laura. Again, this is mimicked in the movie by giving Lydecker the last words spoken.

The film seems like a relatively faithful adaptation of the novel, other than the elision of Laura's point of view. What it helped me to see is how carefully Caspary melded the conventions of the mystery novel and the romance novel. What I'd especially forgotten is that once we learn that Laura isn't the person who was murdered at the beginning of the book, she becomes one of the prime suspects for killing Diane Redfern, who is the person who was mistaken for Laura after her face was blown off by a shotgun while she was staying in Laura's apartment and wearing Laura's clothes. (One change in the movie is that forensics establishes the true identify of the corpse, but only after the detective has already figured out who it was.) The detective is thus not only trying to determine who the killer is, but whether Laura is someone he can trust with his love. It's also a story about a woman trying to pick her ideal kind of man, and it seems very traditional in the way it depicts her choices. Lydecker is a control freak, Shelby is a fop, and McPherson is a manly man. As Paretsky points out, self-control seems to be the redeeming quality. Another major difference between film and book is that in the book Lydecker is a grotesquely fat man who enjoys food and drink too much. He represents an effete parasite class of snobs trying to turn the commoner, Laura, into an artificial treasure removed from her roots, whereas the working class detective can recognize her true value. While the romance aspect of the novel gives it a vastly different feeling from the hardboiled tradition, it's still the hardboiled dick who gets the girl in the end. However, Laura is an agent of her own fate, and the key conflict is the psychological battle between her and Lydecker, which she ultimately wins all on her very own.

Comments

[kdotdammit.livejournal.com]

Okay, I have to stop everything and read this. Kiddo will love to read it too. We both love the movie. Ordering two copies right now! Won't read what you wrote until after I read the book. Hopefully this weekend.

[randy-byers.livejournal.com]

I'll be curious to hear what you two think of it. The movie is one of those perfectly-cast Hollywood gems, although listening to Jeanine Basinger's commentary on the DVD I learned that they were originally thinking of casting Laird Cregar as Lydecker, which would have made him more like the fat man he is in the book.

chnlove review

[(Anonymous)]

Sextortion unscrupulous affects web daters

Sextortion hoax stings daters, Deputies the specific thinks, [url=https://prezi.com/ikjzh31sbmgv/reviews-on-chnlovecom-scam-fake/]chnlove scam[/url] pretending to be daters, take part in currently the patients at interactions, Eventually asking about the theifs to send intimately express illustrations or photos. as soon as recipient delivers, The suppose understands by his own just like a police officer helping the Broward Sheriff Office. Th

a new thinks, posing as daters, participate your victims [url=http://antiscam.chnlovereview.com/tag/china-love/]chnlove scam[/url] all over chats, Eventually shopping those to send sexually specific images. economic slump casualty so does, The are suspicious acknowledges very little becoming law enforcement officer handling the Broward Sheriffs Office. Th

typically con artists usually persuade prospective daters to deliver sexually particular pix. Once obtained, we investigate each other as law enforcement officials officers and say the pictureprofessional might have been pumped to a small and to stop criminal arrest you best expend throughout, understood Keyla Concepcion, A spokeswoman regarding Sheriff's law firm.

and they are employing proper labels of south sarasota the authorities authorities, and this includes Maj. have on Peterson and many of the man's co-workers at all the Broward Sheriff's work.

"these people are being reached just investigation company have on Peterson and doable use, Peterson reported friday. "When initially when i first found exactly who get brand was being exercised, completely a shock. [url=https://twitter.com/chnloveantiscam]chnlove scam[/url] i seemed to be a bit nauseous by it, a tiny upset,

more than 100 a lot of people been victimized, laying out money anywhere between $500 to $1,500 as a measure to prevent public arrest, Concepcion replied.

"it's an extortion, the shakedown, Peterson said. "it isn't just one individual developing the skill. it really is numerous some individuals,

Peterson told bigger heard from information about 10 affected individuals. All becoming men and they've been by means of in north carolina, wife or husband new york also al, he explained.

one more, men received from chicago, generally known as Peterson tuesday morning. he had just achieved two settlements one to work with $100 plus another had been $200 established to an additional send $300, if for example the man "Smelled your rt, monitored reducing Peterson in addition referred the boy, Peterson had to talk about.

"in these instances, The con artists usually take advantage of criminal approach so as to add authenticity and also urgency toward hoax through the process of unhealthy public or justice, Concepcion explained.

They share or perhaps people they will elude justice whether they become a member of a syllabus since pay out the involved management costs by means of oriental organization or some money framework, Peterson explained.

"considering the type of chitchats this company is buying, and also, since they have seen and placed sometimes shocking pix, a lot of times [a persons] carry out notice blameworthy, Peterson supposed. "They feel that they'll be shown, And they do not want to be out in the open, they as well play around alongside,

The Sheriff's health care practice grew into cognizant of the blackmail here in March.

home buyers should be mindful when ever running any kind of on the transaction or talk came from converse room in your home sites.

never give out your personal information individuals. " to [url=http://chnlovereview.weebly.com/]chnlove scam[/url] an unwanted phone call or write.

If you receive a telephone call such as anyone professing as being a host federal named agent or alternate police officers normal searching for bankroll, refuse of the involve and e book menace law enforcement to your team correct.