randy_byers: (cesare)
American film critic and painter Manny Farber just died this week at age 91. I haven't read any of his film criticism yet (just ordered his collection, Negative Space), but I've read about his famous essay, "White Elephant Art Vs. Termite Art," in which he apparently had this to say about Antonioni (an exemplar, in his taxonomy, of white elephant art, which he despised):

Antonioni's specialty, the effect of moving as in a chess game, becomes an autocratic kind of direction that robs an actor of his motive powers and most of his spine. A documentarist at heart and one who often suggests both Paul Klee and a cool, deftly neat, “intellectual” Fred Zinnemann in his early Act Of Violence phase, he gets his odd, clarity-is-all effects from his taste for chic mannerist art that results in a screen that is glassy, has a side-sliding motion, the feeling of people plastered against stripes or divided by vertical and horizontals; his incapacity with interpersonal relationships turns crowds into stiff waves, lovers into lonely appendages hanging stiffly from each other, occasionally coming together like clanking sheets of metal but seldom giving the effect of being in communion.

As the blogger who posted this quote commented, Antonioni's theme was "the alienation resulting from modernity, and humans' incapacity for meaningful relationships," so you could say that Farber is affirming Antonioni's success at communicating his meaning. This characterization of Antonioni's theme is also a pretty good description of what I found off-putting about Blowup. Still, I have thoughts tugging at my backbrain about why I so enjoy Assayas' demonlover when it has similar things to say about modern alienation and the incapacity for meaningful relationships. Is it just that it's more conflicted about the seductive attractions of modernity?

Actually, it's probably because demonlover plays more like a genre thriller than an art movie.
randy_byers: (machine man)
I dunno. I saw this Michelangelo Antonioni film when I was in college and didn't think much of it. I watched it again on DVD last night with [livejournal.com profile] holyoutlaw, and while I appreciate its visual artistry better now, I still don't think much of it. My guess is that what put me off when I was younger was the obnoxious prick of a protagonist, played by David Hemmings. I had a problem with obnoxious prick protagonists when I was younger, because I was so used to identifying with the heroic figures of the fantasy and science fiction that I read as an adolescent. But what put me off this time was the sense of intellectual alienation. I mean, I dunno. I love the sense of desperate existential alienation of post-war film noir, but in art films like Blowup it feels unearned now. It feels like middle class ennui, and what is more tiresome than middle class ennui? It reminds me of the alienation of my college years, which ended up mostly being a fear of growing up.

But there are aspects of the movie I do like. I love the modeling sessions, with their glimpse of high pop fashion in mid-'60s Europe. I love the scene where he wanders into the Yardbirds concert and the audience is standing around like zombies. The swank artist's party is interesting, and I laughed at the stoned line Luke still remembered from his own long ago first viewing: "I *am* in Paris." I love the way the buildings and streets and parks often feel like artificial sets. The film has a very cool look to go along with its emotional distance. The central sequence where he blows up the photographs trying to see whether he really sees anything in the details is fascinating. Conceptually, I like the fact that the murder is treated as a phenomenological rather than criminal problem.

But boy, I have no interest in the protagonist or his existential dilemma, and as far as phenomenological explorations go, give me King Hu's wuxia film, A Touch of Zen (1969), over this kind of thing. In short, give me a paradoxical taoist view over a smug European despair at meaninglessness.

Hm, have I gotten onto a high horse, or did you just sit down?

Well, the hand shaved noodles and pickled pepper fish at the Szechuan Bistro before the movie were terrific, as usual. Just the kind of anti-fungal food you need on a hot, muggy day.

Profile

randy_byers: (Default)
randy_byers

September 2017

S M T W T F S
     12
3456789
10 111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 5th, 2025 03:07 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios